Unlimited Website Traffic: John Patrick Leary: All the Young Technocrats

John Patrick Leary: All the Young Technocrats HPFB.init();

HuffPost's QuickRead...ShareBox.ad = function (tag_id){if ($(tag_id) == undefined) return; if ($(tag_id).innerHTML != '') return;ad_spec = {"zone_info": "huffpost.detroit","ord": 1366066478,"tile": 3,"width": 300,"height": 250,"el_id": tag_id + "_js","class_name": "ad_block ad_wide top","type": "iframe"}HuffPoUtil.WEDGJE.write(ad_spec, tag_id);};Loading... HuffPost's QuickRead...

Detroit Development iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More Log in Create Account Notifications Profile Settings Logout #topnav_margin_btm { margin:0 !important } April 15, 2013

Edition: U.S. CA Canada FR France IT Italia ES España US United States UK United Kingdom FRONT PAGE Politics George W. Bush Welcomes First Grandchild912 Man Shoots Himself To Death At NRA-Sponsored NASCAR Race11k Santorum Trip Cancelled After Hospitalization3k Rubio: Immigration Reform Will Be Harsher Than Current System8k GOP Rep: Mitt Romney Was Right About '47 Percent'7k Go to Politics More in Politics Pollster Politics Blog Speculatron Off The Bus Election Maps You might also like World Green Black Voices Latino Voices Gay Voices Business NSFW: 9 Embarrassing Logos That Make Us Uncomfortable156 Gold Set For Worst 2-Day Loss In 30 Years2k Elderly Couple Alarmed By Find In Safe Deposit Box296 Where To Get Free Or Cheap Food On Tax Day36 LOOK: 10 Most Horrifying Things Landlords Have Done360 Go to Business More in Business Small Business Money You might also like World Tech Media Arts Sports Weird News Crime Entertainment Star EJECTED From MTV Movie Awards After Bizarre Stunt864 Keith Richards' Surprise Performance190 'Avengers' Vanquishes The Competition At MTV Movie Awards127 WATCH: 'Hunger Games' Sequel Gets First Look58 'Flashdance' Is Now 30 Years Old174 Go to Entertainment More in Entertainment Celebrity TV You might also like Comedy Arts Books Food Style Weird News Moviefone Media Networks Go Wall-To-Wall With Marathon Horror95 Shakeup At Katie Couric's Daytime Show56 NY Times Gitmo Op-Ed Draws Outcry487 Pulitzer Prize Winners Announced280 Local Fox Affiliate Criticized For Controversial Promo87 Go to Media More in Media Eat The Press Calderone: The Backstory You might also like Entertainment TV Comedy Arts Books Religion Moviefone Food Soda Giant Unveils Breakfast Drink262 Lay's Unveils Three New (Awesome!) Flavors528 Pizza Hut Perfume Now Available In U.S.147 The World's Most Expensive... Bacon Sandwich?20 Introducing The 'McCamembert'25 Go to Food More in Food Chefs Restaurants Food Safety Fast Food Wine Beer You might also like Taste Travel Green Arts Turkish Pianist Jailed For Twitter Comments105 Happy Birthday Leonardo Da Vinci!15 A Jazz Classic Gets A Mind-Blowing Update80 Your April Reading List London Symphony Conductor Dies At 85 Go to Arts More in Arts Painting Film Design Photography Theater Architecture You might also like Books New York Los Angeles Sports The Master From Down Under1k Tiger Leaves Masters Empty-Handed869 Tiger Avoids Disqualification3k LOOK: New York Post Jokes About Tiger's 'Balls'174 Thriller In Boston Go to Sports More in Sports NFL College Football MLB Fails Highlights You might also like TV Food Tech Comedy Weird News Black Voices Officer Fired For Bringing Trayvon Martin Target To Gun Range11k Lauryn Hill Makes Another Interesting Tax Claim20 PHOTOS: The Week's Best Style Moments Jamie Foxx's Bold Fashion Statement54 PHOTOS: Kerry Brings Back The Mullet Dress Go to Black Voices More in Black Voices Power & Politics Pop Culture Fashion & Beauty Life Sunday Magazine You might also like Latino Voices Gay Voices Arts Comedy Food Education Superintendent: How Did Shooter Get Past Metal Detectors? 5k Bill Gates: Education Should Be America's Top Concern526 Students Write On Sandpaper Until Fingers Bleed, Teacher On Leave625 Parents, Students Upset Over Teacher's Violent Test Questions957 Schools' Realistic Shooting Drills 'Kind Of Scary,' Parents Say27 Go to Education More in Education Education Reform Teachers Bullying Ed-Lection 2012 You might also like College Teen Impact Parents Healthy Living LIVE Now Hilarity For Charity Next Sex Ed To The Rescue Coming Up Nia Vardalos Coming Up Students On Trial Coming Up Migrant Children In Fear Go to HuffPost Live ALL SECTIONS NewsPoliticsWorldBusinessSmall BusinessMoneyMediaSportsEducationCrimeWeird NewsGood NewsEntertainmentEntertainmentCelebrityComedyArts & CultureBooksTVLife & StyleHealthy LivingGPS for the SoulStyleHomeFoodTaste WeddingsTravelParentsDivorceHuff/Post 50Marlo ThomasOWNTech & ScienceTechScienceGreenTEDWeekendsVoicesWomenBlack VoicesLatino VoicesVoces (en español)Gay VoicesReligionCollegeTeenImpactLocalChicagoDCDenverDetroitMiamiNew YorkLos AngelesSan FranciscoOur Mobile Apps iPhoneiPadHuffPost Live iPadAndroid PhoneAndroid Tablet AutoblogTranslogicPatch.comDetroitDetroit TigersDetroit PoliticsDetroit EducationAround TownRestaurantsReal EstateImpactBest of DetroitDetroit Sports

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributorsHot on the BlogKeith OlbermannRichard CurtisJeffrey SachsLeo W. Gerard

John Patrick LearyAssistant Professor of English, Wayne State University

GET UPDATES FROM John Patrick Leary Like 8 All the Young Technocrats Posted: 04/15/2013 5:14 pm Read more

Detroit Politics , Detroit Development , Evgeny Morozov , Solutionism , Detroit News
#news_entries #ad_sharebox_260x60 img {padding:0px;margin:0px} share this story Submit this storydiggredditstumble

The "White Entrepreneurial Detroit Guy" meme has touched a nerve, diagnosing exhaustion with a media infatuation with altruistic entrepreneurs. Many of the captions that have appeared thus far -- "Let them drink pourovers" -- are funny, but all of them are laced with much more bitterness than your average Internet joke. (Bitter, like an Ethiopian pourover gone cold?) It's worth considering what is actually behind the venom: It's not just mockery of "hipsters," or business owners, or non-native Detroiters, or God forbid, a case of "reverse racism."

The unfortunate subject of the meme, Jason Lorimer, set it all off with a tone-deaf article, "Detroit is the Opportunity of a Generation," in Model D, a local booster publication. Lorimer's article had big ambitions: to lay out a generational vision for Detroit while promoting his consulting company, Dandelion. "Cities advertise they are open for business," Lorimer writes, "but Detroit is open for changemakers. Cities advertise tax incentives, but Detroit is an opportunity to iterate alongside a community of doers and define the model for the post-industrial American city."

The article is so ridden with jargon that it reads like it was written by someone who has learned English entirely by watching TEDTalks. The lack of self-awareness was striking -- the absent sense that a little humility and dues-paying go a long way, especially for a white person of means in this city -- and the audacity of misappropriating the anti-colonial revolutionary Frantz Fanon as a consulting guru didn't help. Consider this befuddling description from Dandelion's homepage, in a poster unhelpfully titled "Dandelion Does," promising as it does to explain what Dandelion, in fact, does:

"A civic or social-issue investor comes to Dandelion with systemic issues that need measurable solutions. For example, homelessness in the community, truancy in the schools or a lack of a vibrant main street. Out entire tactical team studies the issue from all angles, for as long as it takes to make your problem our own."

Note the grand ambitions here: A little consulting firm will address homelessness or truancy "for as long as it takes to make your problem our own" (shouldn't homelessness already be "our" problem?). There's the recognition that such problems are "systemic" -- that is, they are symptoms of deeper societal failings with complex structures. Yet the solution to such systemic problems not in political activism but individual "innovation," not in social change but rather in heroic "changemakers."

But it would be unfair to pick on Dandelion exclusively. I, too, feel implicated by the meme, since I move easily in these same gentrifying precincts around Wayne State and downtown. The city's profound racial and neighborhood segregation, as persistent as ever, is in some ways the biggest problem signaled by the " entrepreneurial guy." But what the meme also mocks is a way of thinking about social change as an individual, technocratic, and even profitable affair. The Silicon Valley critic Evgeny Morozov, in his excellent new book To Save Everything, Click Here has a term for this way of thinking:

"Recasting all complex social situations either as neatly defined problems with definite, computable solutions or as transparent and self-evident processes that can be easily optimized -- if only the right algorithms are in place!...I call the ideology that legitimizes and sanctions such aspirations 'solutionism.'"

Solutionism, in the context of the media-friendly Detroit of Midtown, Corktown, and the Dan Gilbert-controlled area of downtown, combines a utopian idealism with the technocratic fantasy that systemic problems can be managed away with the right experts and right digital tools. You can see why this appeals to austerity-minded politicians -- "turnkeying" (this is apparently now a transitive verb) truancy is cheaper and gets better press than the apparently impossible task of funding urban public schools. Perpetually summoning "doers" to "innovate" "solutions" to urban unemployment is easier than actually doing so. If only we could mass-produce buzzwords in one of our vacant factories.

Another example of solutionism is a recent project of Corktown's Imagination Station. As reported by Michigan Radio, the group has developed a tool in response to Detroit failure to collect taxes on 50 percent of properties held in the city: a website that makes it easier to pay property taxes. A cynic might point out that of all the reasons that the city fails to collect property taxes, the technical difficulty of paying them surely ranks far, far down the list. Alas, there's no iPhone app that can rehire laid-off city tax assessors or battle speculators, like the notorious Grosse Pointe Woods investor Mike Kelly, the largest private landowner in Detroit. According to a 2007 University of Michigan study cited by the Detroit News, Kelly's company failed to pay taxes on one-third of its Detroit purchases over a two-year period.

The lure of technocratic solutionism also lends itself easily to defenses of Kevyn Orr, the city's Emergency Manager charged with settling the city's debts to Wall Street bondholders. In his case, a systemic problem, the city's impoverishment and indebtedness, is redefined as "fiscal instability" or "financial mismanagement" -- an elegant reframing of a structural problem as a management problem. See? All we need are new people, presumably with some better calculators and faster Internet connection.

One could ignore the "White Detroit entrepreneurial guy" as a harmless joke, or a mean one. But the "good intentions" the joke mocks are not just harmless delusions, but pernicious distractions that waste the idealistic energy of many young people in Detroit.

Follow John Patrick Leary on Twitter:www.twitter.com/JohnPatLeary

FOLLOW DETROIT Like 5k Get Alerts #ad_bottom_article_text {margin-bottom: 15px} Detroit DevelopmentDetroit PoliticsThe "White Entrepreneurial Detroit Guy" meme has touched a nerve, diagnosing exhaustion with a media infatuation with altruistic entrepreneurs. Many of the captions that have appeared thus far -- "Let...The "White Entrepreneurial Detroit Guy" meme has touched a nerve, diagnosing exhaustion with a media infatuation with altruistic entrepreneurs. Many of the captions that have appeared thus far -- "Let...