Peter T. Coleman, PhD: Communicating With Rogue States: The Power of the Weak

Peter T. Coleman, PhD: Communicating With Rogue States: The Power of the Weak HPFB.init();
HuffPost's QuickRead...ShareBox.ad = function (tag_id){if ($(tag_id) == undefined) return; if ($(tag_id).innerHTML != '') return;ad_spec = {"zone_info": "huffpost.world","ord": 1366066656,"tile": 3,"width": 300,"height": 250,"el_id": tag_id + "_js","class_name": "ad_block ad_wide top","type": "iframe"}HuffPoUtil.WEDGJE.write(ad_spec, tag_id);};Loading... HuffPost's QuickRead... Loading... Venezuela iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More Log in Create Account Notifications Profile Settings Logout #topnav_margin_btm { margin:0 !important } April 15, 2013 Edition: U.S. CA Canada FR France IT Italia ES España US United States UK United Kingdom FRONT PAGE Politics George W. Bush Welcomes First Grandchild912 Man Shoots Himself To Death At NRA-Sponsored NASCAR Race11k Santorum Trip Cancelled After Hospitalization3k Rubio: Immigration Reform Will Be Harsher Than Current System8k GOP Rep: Mitt Romney Was Right About '47 Percent'7k Go to Politics More in Politics Pollster Politics Blog Speculatron Off The Bus Election Maps You might also like World Green Black Voices Latino Voices Gay Voices Business NSFW: 9 Embarrassing Logos That Make Us Uncomfortable156 Gold Set For Worst 2-Day Loss In 30 Years2k Elderly Couple Alarmed By Find In Safe Deposit Box296 Where To Get Free Or Cheap Food On Tax Day36 LOOK: 10 Most Horrifying Things Landlords Have Done360 Go to Business More in Business Small Business Money You might also like World Tech Media Arts Sports Weird News Crime Entertainment Star EJECTED From MTV Movie Awards After Bizarre Stunt864 Keith Richards' Surprise Performance190 'Avengers' Vanquishes The Competition At MTV Movie Awards127 WATCH: 'Hunger Games' Sequel Gets First Look58 'Flashdance' Is Now 30 Years Old174 Go to Entertainment More in Entertainment Celebrity TV You might also like Comedy Arts Books Food Style Weird News Moviefone Media Networks Go Wall-To-Wall With Marathon Horror95 Shakeup At Katie Couric's Daytime Show56 NY Times Gitmo Op-Ed Draws Outcry487 Pulitzer Prize Winners Announced280 Local Fox Affiliate Criticized For Controversial Promo87 Go to Media More in Media Eat The Press Calderone: The Backstory You might also like Entertainment TV Comedy Arts Books Religion Moviefone Green PHOTOS: Rare Camel, Sumatran Tiger Cub And More Animals Antarctica's Ice Melt Hits Dismal Milestone2k Fire Wipes Out Reptile House At Scotland Zoo76 PHOTOS: Can You Tell What Is Covering This Beach?387 PHOTO: What Is Flowing Out Of That Pipe?133 Go to Green More in Green Energy Climate Change Animals Green Tech Green Holiday You might also like Politics Food World Science Healthy Living Tech Arts Turkish Pianist Jailed For Twitter Comments105 Happy Birthday Leonardo Da Vinci!15 A Jazz Classic Gets A Mind-Blowing Update80 Your April Reading List London Symphony Conductor Dies At 85 Go to Arts More in Arts Painting Film Design Photography Theater Architecture You might also like Books New York Los Angeles Travel FAA Orders Inspections Of Boeing 737s119 Your Weekly Travel Zen: India The Most Romantic Hotels Of The South How To Eat For (Mostly) Free On The Road America's Best Places To Eat Like A Local23 Go to Travel More in Travel Travel Video Destinations Themed Guides TSA Airlines You might also like Food Arts World GPS for the Soul Recipes Food Soda Giant Unveils Breakfast Drink262 Lay's Unveils Three New (Awesome!) Flavors528 Pizza Hut Perfume Now Available In U.S.147 The World's Most Expensive... Bacon Sandwich?20 Introducing The 'McCamembert'25 Go to Food More in Food Chefs Restaurants Food Safety Fast Food Wine Beer You might also like Taste Travel Green LIVE Now Hilarity For Charity Next Sex Ed To The Rescue Coming Up Nia Vardalos Coming Up Students On Trial Coming Up Migrant Children In Fear Go to HuffPost Live ALL SECTIONS NewsPoliticsWorldBusinessSmall BusinessMoneyMediaSportsEducationCrimeWeird NewsGood NewsEntertainmentEntertainmentCelebrityComedyArts & CultureBooksTVLife & StyleHealthy LivingGPS for the SoulStyleHomeFoodTaste WeddingsTravelParentsDivorceHuff/Post 50Marlo ThomasOWNTech & ScienceTechScienceGreenTEDWeekendsVoicesWomenBlack VoicesLatino VoicesVoces (en español)Gay VoicesReligionCollegeTeenImpactLocalChicagoDCDenverDetroitMiamiNew YorkLos AngelesSan FranciscoOur Mobile Apps iPhoneiPadHuffPost Live iPadAndroid PhoneAndroid Tablet WorldIsrael-Gaza ConflictForeign AffairsDrug WarAfghanistan WarSyriaWorld Videos .header-search {margin-bottom: 0px;}
Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributorsHot on the BlogKeith OlbermannRichard CurtisJeffrey SachsLeo W. Gerard
Peter T. Coleman, PhDProfessor of Psychology and Education, Columbia University

GET UPDATES FROM Peter T. Coleman, PhD   Like 6 Communicating With Rogue States: The Power of the Weak Posted: 04/15/2013 5:17 pm Follow   North Korea ,   Iran ,   Syria , Peace , Peace Negotiations , Peace , Un , World News
#news_entries #ad_sharebox_260x60 img {padding:0px;margin:0px} share this story Submit this storydiggredditstumble

Syria, North Korea, and Iran. Today these three nations share the dubious distinction of being labeled by the international community as well-armed rogue states ruled by leaders who are insane, criminal, or worse and who pose grave threats to regional stability and peace. They also share the fact that they have completely stymied the UN, the U.S. and most of the international community, who currently appear to have few viable solutions on the table for mitigating the escalating hostilities and rhetoric.

How can the UN or the U.S. break these deadlocks and avert new waves of atrocities or nuclear catastrophe? Most likely they can't. Constrained by their own policies, histories, symbolism and strategies, they are probably among the last actors in the international community with the power to ratchet down tensions with these nations. They are ironically too prominent and powerful.

Intractable, entrenched patterns of destructive conflicts like these typically reject out of hand strong-arm attempts pressing for peace and stability, or even less coercive approaches to statist diplomacy or third-party mediation. History provides countless examples of the UN, the US and other powerful outside parties' failing to forge peace in such enmity systems. Israel-Palestine, Cyprus, and Kashmir stand as three contemporary examples.

Nevertheless, peace does sometimes emerge out of long-term conflicts, and one path is through the power of powerlessness. That is, the unique influence of people and groups with little formal or "hard" power (military might, economic incentives, legal or human rights justifications, and so on) but with relevant "soft" power (trustworthiness, moral authority, wisdom, kindness, etc.) can have in these settings. Hard-power approaches in high-intensity conflicts tend to elicit greater resistance and intransigence from their targets. Weak-power third parties are at times able to weaken resistance to change by carefully introducing a sense of alternative courses-of-action, hope for change, or even a sense of questioning and doubt in the ultra-certain status quo of "us versus them" conflicts. They can also begin to model and encourage other more constructive means of conflict engagement such as shuttle diplomacy and indirect communications through negotiation chains.

In other words, what the world needs today are a few good weaklings.

Like Monsignor Jaime Gonçalves and the Community of Sant'Egidio in Mozambique in 1990. At the time Mozambique, which had won independence from Portugal in 1975, was in the throes of a bloody civil war that had killed one million of its 12 million people and ravaged the country for over 16 years. The continual interference of the neighboring anti-independence countries, Rhodesia and South Africa, made the emergence of a peaceful solution highly improbable. The international community tried and failed on many occasions. And the many failed peace attempts merely contributed to the peoples' hopelessness and increased resistance to new intervention. Ideologically, militarily, and politically there was no way for non-contentious communication and exchange between the warring groups. It was an impossible conflict.

While the violent conflict between the FRELIMO government and the RENAMO rebels in Mozambique became more entrenched, an unexpected group of actors began to explore alternatives. A young native, national bishop Monsignor Jaime Gonçalves was linked to the Community of Sant'Egidio, a Catholic lay association that had already engaged with the FRELIMO government to facilitate religious freedoms there in the 1970s. These efforts had been successful, so Mozambique's president, Joachim Chissano, sought the help of Sant'Egidio to establish back-channel contacts with RENAMO.

Initially, Sant'Egidio met enormous challenges. Its power to exert influence was very limited, as was its recognition by the international community, and so communication with the leaders in Mozambique proved difficult. But using its channels, Sant'Egidio arranged for a clandestine visit of Bishop Gonçalves to RENAMO headquarters deep in the jungle. At this meeting, Bishop Gonzales and Alfonso Dlakama, the leader of RENAMO, were surprised (and lucky) to discover they were from the same ethnic tribe and spoke the same dialect. Their meeting was the beginning of an unpredictable series of events leading to an unorthodox journey to peace that included 27 months of negotiations over eleven sessions, resulting in the signing of the General Peace Agreement (GPA) on October 4, 1992.

In Mozambique, we saw the emergence of peace sparked by the actions of a few locally trusted actors. Change emerged at the margins through nonthreatening communications allowing decision-makers to begin to consider alternatives to the conflict. This initial consideration was made possible by the "weaknesses" of the proponents. Weak mediators, not perceived as a threat or source of pressure, can disrupt the certainty and constraints of enemy dynamics and begin to relax internal pressures for consensus.

This is not unlike to the role that Leymah Gbowee and the Women's International Peace Network (WIPN) played in the early 2000s, when they helped end Liberia's decades-long civil wars. This ordinary group of women -- mothers, aunts and grandmothers -- organized amid the grueling armed conflict in Liberia, with no formal authority and few "hard" resources -- and helped mobilize and shepherd the peace process between the government of strongman Charles Taylor and the rebels. For example, at one point in the war, UN peacekeepers were stuck in a protracted gun battle with rebel forces in the jungle and could see no way out. They contacted the WIPN, who arrived at the scene in their white T-shirts and headdresses. The women then entered the jungle with hands raised, dancing and singing. After spending two days there, feeding and speaking with the rebels, the women brought the rebels out of the jungle, ending the stalemate.

The moral: Weak power can be immensely powerful.

The UN, the U.S. and other nation states interested in fostering stability and peace in Syria, North Korea, and Iran can learn much from these examples.

First, the UN and the international community of nations need to see beyond themselves and their own capacities for brokering peace. Traditionally, peace processes are conceived of as attempts at bringing disputing parties to the negotiation table and securing an agreement which facilitates peace. However in studies we have conducted with effective peacemakers, they describe a much more complex scene; a multitude of inter-related stakeholder groups which extend far beyond those more readily identified as disputants and third parties, including the general population, marginalized groups, extremist groups, the diaspora, civil society, the elite, academics, informal decision-makers, funding agencies, community institutions, business and industry, activist groups, and agnostics (relatively unaware, uninterested, or unwilling groups whose active involvement is seen as critical for peace). This means that a wide variety of actors and constructive processes may be available, in addition to direct negotiations and mediation, for bringing about a host of complementary objectives related to readying, triggering and establishing sustainable peace.

Second, they need to understand the nature of the role they are playing in this complex system of conflict and peace. The pressures imposed by the international community on regimes such as Syria, North Korea, and Iran today are a critical -- but insufficient -- condition for peace. Research has shown that disputants locked in protracted conflicts become ripe for negotiating peace when two basic conditions are met: 1) they find themselves in an unwinnable, mutually hurting stalemate and 2) they can see a way out of the conflict. Actions by the international community today in Syria, for example, largely increase the pain of stalemate. What is missing is a vision of a feasible way out.

Third, they need to do what they can to support non-state actors like the Community of Sant'Egidio and WIPN and, even more importantly, not interfere in their efforts. Like it or not, the more powerful actors in the international community are not alone out there, and the sooner we recognize and learn to work effectively and constructively within our complex systems of war and peace, the better.

Peter T. Coleman, PhD is a social psychologist on faculty at The Earth Institute and Teachers College at Columbia University, Director of the International Center for Cooperation and Conflict Resolution, and author of the books: The Five Percent: Finding Solutions to Seemingly Impossible Conflicts (2011) and Psychology's Contributions to Sustainable Peace (with Morton Deutsch, 2012).

 FOLLOW WORLD Like 81k   Get Alerts SyriaIranPeaceNorth Korea     Comments0Pending Comments0 View FAQ Previewing Your Comment. This comment has not yet been posted You have exceeded your word limit by    words. Please click the "Edit" button and shorten your comment.

Post Comment Edit Cancel

You can post to us this information Contact us Click here to leave a comment.HuffPost High School welcomes a lively, thoughtful debate in the comment section. Keep in mind that the articles here are penned by young authors, so please keep criticism respectful, and help us to keep this a safe and supportive place for writers of all ages to contribute.Post CommentPreview Comment To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to. Post Comment Preview Comment To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.

Share your Comment:

Post to Facebook. Post to Blogger. Post to Twitter. Post to WordPress. Post to TypePad. Post to Tumblr. Post to Yahoo! Blogger login: Blogger password: Select blog: refresh list Remember me: Wordpress host: Wordpress login: Wordpress password: Remember me: TypePad host: TypePad login: TypePad password: Select blog: refresh list Remember me: Tumblr login: Tumblr password: Remember me: Community Notice:  We've made some changes to our badge program, including the addition
of our newest badge: Community Curator. View All Recency |  Popularity    new comment(s) on this entry — Click to refreshLoading comments… Most Popular Boston Marathon Explosion Man Shoots Himself To Death At NRA-Sponsored NASCAR Race Justin Bieber Wishes Anne Frank Could Have Been A Belieber JFK Library Explosion Investigated Boston Marathon Explosion Footage (GRAPHIC VIDEO) NSFW: 9 Embarrassing Logos That Make Us Uncomfortable The Master From Down Under Kristen Stewart & Robert Pattinson Cozy Up At Coachella Star EJECTED From MTV Movie Awards After Bizarre Stunt WATCH: 'Hunger Games' Sequel Gets First Look LOOK: Dad's Awesome Response To Stranger At Wal-Mart 'SNL' Takes On Gun Control Deftones Bassist Dies At 42 PHOTO: Pig Born With 2 Heads Company Recalls 468,000 Pounds Of Meat Over Bacteria Concerns GOP Senator's Outrageous Comments About Newtown Victims Follow HuffPost Email Facebook Twitter Google Plus RSS Mobile HuffPost Daily Brief World Get top stories and blogs posts emailed to you each day.

HuffPost World HuffPost World HuffPost World Most Popular on HuffPost Latest News World View all RSS feeds TurboTax Outage on Eve of Tax Day Panics Procrastinators

At Least 2 Dead After Boston Marathon Explosions — Twitter Reacts After News of Blasts at Finish Line

After Asking Students to ‘Explain Why Jews Are Evil,’ Teacher Placed on Leave

Time - World  
Advertise | Make HuffPost your Home Page | RSS | Careers | FAQ User Agreement | Privacy | Comment Policy | About Us | About Our Ads | Contact Us Copyright © 2013 TheHuffingtonPost.com, Inc. | "The Huffington Post" is a registered trademark of TheHuffingtonPost.com, Inc. All rights reserved. Part of HPMG News
HuffPost Lightbox

View the original article here